← GALLERY IX EXHIBITS
The Platform Economy
GALLERY IX

The Platform Economy

The platform economy emerged from packet-switching networks (1969–) into a revolutionary system of intermediation, matching supply and demand at scale. By 2010–2020, platforms like Uber, Airbnb, and Amazon reshaped labor, commerce, and social life—a digital-age transformation as disruptive as steam and electricity.
No single hero; rather, a distributed cast: J.C.R. Licklider (visionary of human-computer symbiosis, 1960), Bob Taylor and Lawrence G. Roberts (ARPANET architects, 1966–69), Vint Cerf and Bob Kahn (TCP/IP protocol, 1973–78), Tim Berners-Lee (World Wide Web, 1989–91), and the entrepreneurs who weaponized the web—Jeff Bezos (Amazon, 1994), Evan Williams and Jack Dorsey (Twitter, 2006), Travis Kalanick and Garrett Camp (Uber, 2009), Brian Chesky and Joe Gebbia (Airbnb, 2008). The true revolution was collective: thousands of engineers, venture capitalists, and users who saw the network not as a library but as a marketplace.

Specifications

Launch Era
1969 (ARPANET) to 2004–2010 (Web 2.0 platforms)
Labor Model
Gig work, algorithmic management, contractor classification
Business Model
Two-sided or multi-sided markets; network effects; data extraction
Core Technology
Packet switching, TCP/IP, HTTP/HTTPS, cloud computing
Primary Markets
Transportation, lodging, e-commerce, social media, food delivery
Scale (by 2020)
4.5+ billion internet users; trillions of transactions annually
Geographic Reach
Global, with regulatory fragmentation
Key Infrastructure
Distributed servers, APIs, mobile apps, data centers

Engineering

The platform economy rests on three engineering pillars. First, packet-switching networks (ARPANET, 1969; Internet Protocol, 1983) enabled asynchronous, decentralized communication at scale—no central switchboard required. Second, the World Wide Web (HTTP, HTML, URLs, 1989–91) created a universal, human-readable interface that abstracted network complexity. Third, cloud computing (Amazon Web Services, 2006 onward) commodified server capacity, allowing startups to scale without owning infrastructure. Layered atop these are APIs (application programming interfaces) that permit third-party developers to plug into platforms, and machine-learning algorithms that optimize matching (Uber's dispatch, Airbnb's search ranking, Amazon's recommendations). The smartphone (iPhone, 2007; Android, 2008) became the primary interface, collapsing geography and enabling real-time, location-aware transactions. Critically, platforms employ data collection and algorithmic governance to extract behavioral surplus—every interaction feeds recommendation engines and pricing models.

Parts & Labels

ARPANET (1969)
First packet-switched network; four nodes (UCLA, Stanford, UCSB, University of Utah); proved concept of distributed, resilient communication.
APIs & Webhooks
Machine-readable interfaces allowing third-party integration; enabled ecosystem effects (Uber's driver app, Airbnb's booking widget).
Data Centers & CDNs
Geographically distributed servers; content delivery networks (Akamai, Cloudflare); reduced latency and enabled global scale.
World Wide Web (1989–91)
Tim Berners-Lee's system of hyperlinked documents; HTTP (Hypertext Transfer Protocol) and HTML (markup language); made the Internet accessible to non-specialists.
Search Engines (Google, 1998)
Algorithmic indexing of the web; PageRank algorithm; transformed information discovery and advertising into a platform business.
Cloud Infrastructure (AWS, 2006)
On-demand compute, storage, and networking; enabled startups to scale without capital expenditure on data centers.
TCP/IP Protocol Suite (1973–83)
Transmission Control Protocol and Internet Protocol; standardized packet routing and delivery; enabled heterogeneous networks to interoperate.
Payment Systems (Stripe, PayPal, Square)
Abstracted payment processing; enabled peer-to-peer and marketplace transactions; reduced friction for buyers and sellers.
Machine Learning & Recommendation Engines
Neural networks trained on user behavior; optimized matching, pricing, and content ranking; central to platform lock-in.
Mobile Operating Systems (iOS 2007, Android 2008)
Touchscreen interfaces; app stores; location services; enabled ubiquitous platform access and real-time transactions.

Historical Overview

The platform economy did not emerge overnight but evolved through three overlapping phases. Phase One (1969–1995): foundational networks. ARPANET (1969) proved packet switching; the Internet Protocol (1983) unified disparate networks; the World Wide Web (1989–91) made the network human-readable. Phase Two (1995–2004): the dot-com boom and bust. Netscape (1994), Amazon (1994), and eBay (1995) demonstrated that the web could mediate commerce. The 2000–2001 crash winnowed the field, but survivors like Amazon and eBay proved the model's durability. Phase Three (2004–2020): the rise of mobile platforms and data-driven intermediation. Google (2004 IPO) showed that algorithmic advertising could scale; Facebook (2004, IPO 2012) demonstrated network effects in social connection; the iPhone (2007) and Android (2008) made platforms ubiquitous. Uber (2009), Airbnb (2008), and TaskRabbit (2008) extended the model to labor and physical assets. By 2020, platforms had become the dominant form of digital commerce and social coordination, rivaling or exceeding the market power of traditional corporations. The shift was not merely technological but ideological: from the Internet as a public commons (1970s–1990s) to the Internet as a proprietary marketplace (2000s–2010s).

Why It Existed

Platforms emerged to solve a fundamental economic problem: information asymmetry and transaction costs. Before Uber, finding a taxi required knowledge of local regulations, phone numbers, and driver reliability; Uber's algorithm solved matching and trust. Before Airbnb, renting a spare room required word-of-mouth or classified ads; Airbnb automated discovery, payment, and reputation. Before Amazon, retail required physical presence or mail-order catalogs; Amazon's logistics and recommendation engine collapsed geography. Platforms also exploited network effects: the more drivers on Uber, the faster pickups; the more listings on Airbnb, the better selection; the more sellers on Amazon, the broader inventory. Venture capital and the 'growth-at-all-costs' ethos of Silicon Valley accelerated this shift. Tax arbitrage (platforms claiming to be 'technology companies' rather than employers or landlords) and regulatory gaps allowed them to undercut incumbents. Critically, platforms extracted value from user data—every search, click, and transaction fed machine-learning models that improved matching and pricing, creating a feedback loop of increasing returns. By the 2010s, platforms had become the dominant form of digital intermediation because they were faster, cheaper, and more convenient than traditional institutions, even as they externalized costs (worker precarity, housing inflation, tax avoidance) onto society.

Daily Use

For a driver on Uber in 2015: wake at 5 a.m., open the Uber Driver app, accept ride requests dispatched by an algorithm that predicts demand and surge pricing. The app shows the passenger's destination, rating, and pickup location in real time. Payment is automatic; the platform takes a 25–30% commission. No employment contract, no benefits, no guaranteed minimum wage. For an Airbnb host: list a spare room or apartment on the platform, upload photos, set a nightly rate. The algorithm surfaces the listing based on reviews, price, and availability. Guests book directly; Airbnb processes payment and takes 3% from the host, 14–16% from the guest. For an Amazon shopper: search for a product, read algorithmic recommendations ('customers who bought this also bought...'), add to cart, checkout in seconds. The platform handles logistics, returns, and disputes. For a TaskRabbit user: post a task (furniture assembly, moving, cleaning), receive bids from vetted taskers, hire the cheapest or highest-rated, pay through the app. The platform takes 20–30% of the transaction. In all cases, the user surrenders data—location, preferences, behavior—to the platform's machine-learning models, which optimize pricing, matching, and recommendations. The experience is frictionless and convenient; the cost is opaque.

Crew / Personnel

Platforms employ a lean core of engineers, product managers, and executives, but coordinate vast networks of external actors. At Uber (2015): ~2,000 full-time employees (engineers, designers, operations, legal, policy) but ~500,000 drivers (contractors, not employees). At Amazon (2015): ~230,000 employees but millions of third-party sellers. At Airbnb (2015): ~1,500 employees but 1+ million hosts. This structure—small core, large periphery—is deliberate. It minimizes labor costs and regulatory exposure while maximizing scale. Platform workers (drivers, taskers, sellers) are classified as independent contractors, not employees, denying them wages, benefits, or legal protections. This classification is contested: California's Proposition 22 (2020) exempted rideshare and delivery platforms from classifying drivers as employees, but other jurisdictions (EU, UK) have ruled otherwise. The platform's algorithm—not a human manager—assigns work, sets pay, and enforces rules. This 'algorithmic management' obscures accountability and enables platforms to claim neutrality ('we're just a technology company'). In reality, the algorithm embeds choices about fairness, efficiency, and profit that reflect the platform's interests, not the workers'.

Construction

Platforms were not built from scratch but assembled from existing technologies and business models. The technical stack: ARPANET and TCP/IP provided the network; the Web provided the interface; cloud computing (AWS, 2006) provided the infrastructure; mobile operating systems (iOS, Android) provided the distribution channel. The business model drew on eBay's marketplace (2-sided matching), Amazon's logistics (fulfillment and returns), Google's advertising (algorithmic ranking and pricing), and venture capital's growth-at-all-costs ethos. The first platforms (Amazon, eBay, 1995) were built by engineers and entrepreneurs who understood both technology and commerce. Uber and Airbnb (2008–2009) were built by designers and product managers who focused on user experience and network effects, not technology innovation. By the 2010s, platform construction had become a template: (1) identify a fragmented market with high transaction costs; (2) build a mobile app that reduces friction; (3) use algorithmic matching and pricing to optimize the marketplace; (4) extract data to improve the algorithm; (5) scale aggressively, often at a loss, to capture market share; (6) once dominant, raise prices and extract rents. The construction process was iterative and data-driven: platforms launched with minimal features, gathered user feedback, and refined the algorithm. Critically, platforms did not 'disrupt' markets in a neutral sense; they restructured power and value extraction. Uber did not invent the taxi; it reorganized the taxi industry to shift value from drivers to the platform (and passengers, initially). Airbnb did not invent short-term rentals; it commodified housing and shifted value from landlords to the platform and guests.

Variations

Platforms vary by market and business model. Marketplaces (eBay, Amazon, Etsy) connect buyers and sellers of goods; the platform takes a commission. Labor platforms (Uber, TaskRabbit, Upwork) connect service providers and customers; the platform takes a commission and controls the algorithm. Social platforms (Facebook, Twitter, TikTok) connect users and advertisers; the platform extracts data and sells targeted advertising. Subscription platforms (Netflix, Spotify, Apple Music) offer unlimited access to content for a monthly fee; the platform aggregates supply and controls distribution. Hybrid platforms (Amazon) combine multiple models: e-commerce (commission), advertising (sponsored listings), and subscriptions (Prime). Geographic variations: platforms in the US (Uber, Airbnb) operate with minimal regulation; in the EU, they face stricter labor and data-protection rules; in China, they compete with state-backed alternatives (Didi, Alibaba). Regulatory variations: some jurisdictions (California, UK) have ruled that platform workers are employees; others (Texas, Florida) have exempted platforms from labor law. Technological variations: some platforms (Uber) rely on real-time algorithmic matching; others (Amazon) rely on search and recommendation; still others (Facebook) rely on social graphs and feed algorithms. The common thread: all platforms extract value by reducing transaction costs, optimizing matching, and extracting data.

Timeline

DateEvent
1969ARPANET launched with four nodes First packet-switched network; proof of concept for distributed communication
1983TCP/IP protocol standardized Unified heterogeneous networks; enabled the modern Internet
1989Tim Berners-Lee proposes the World Wide Web HTTP and HTML; made the Internet accessible to non-specialists
1994Amazon and Netscape founded E-commerce and web browsers enter the mainstream
1995eBay founded First major two-sided marketplace; peer-to-peer commerce at scale
1998Google founded Search and algorithmic ranking; foundation for data-driven platforms
2004Facebook launched; Google IPO Social platforms and algorithmic advertising enter the mainstream
2006Amazon Web Services (AWS) launched Cloud computing; enabled startups to scale without owning infrastructure
2007iPhone released Mobile computing; platforms become ubiquitous and location-aware
2008Airbnb and Stripe founded Housing and payments; platforms extend to physical assets and peer-to-peer transactions
2009Uber founded Labor platforms; gig economy emerges
2020Platform dominance; regulatory backlash begins Platforms control vast markets; labor and antitrust scrutiny intensify

Famous Examples

Lyft
Founded 2012; by 2020, ~1 million drivers; valued at $24+ billion. Competed with Uber in rideshare; faced similar labor and regulatory challenges.
Uber
Founded 2009; by 2020, ~4 million drivers in 70+ countries; valued at $120+ billion. Pioneered algorithmic dispatch, surge pricing, and contractor classification. Disrupted taxi industries globally but faced labor and regulatory challenges.
Airbnb
Founded 2008; by 2020, ~7 million listings in 220+ countries; valued at $100+ billion. Commodified housing and short-term rentals; enabled peer-to-peer lodging at scale. Faced housing-shortage and tax-avoidance criticism.
Amazon
Founded 1994; by 2020, $386 billion in revenue; 1.3 million employees; dominant in e-commerce, cloud computing, and advertising. Pioneered logistics, recommendations, and AWS. Became the template for platform dominance.
Google
Founded 1998; by 2020, $183 billion in revenue (mostly search advertising). Pioneered algorithmic ranking and data-driven advertising. Became synonymous with search and information intermediation.
WeWork
Founded 2010; by 2019, valued at $47 billion (later collapsed to ~$3 billion). Pioneered shared-workspace platforms; relied on real-estate arbitrage and venture-capital subsidies.
DoorDash
Founded 2013; by 2020, ~400,000 dashers; valued at $32+ billion. Pioneered food-delivery platforms; relied on contractor labor and algorithmic routing.
Facebook
Founded 2004; by 2020, 2.8 billion users; $117 billion in revenue (mostly advertising). Pioneered social-graph algorithms and targeted advertising. Faced privacy and antitrust scrutiny.
Instacart
Founded 2012; by 2020, ~500,000 shoppers; valued at $39+ billion. Pioneered grocery-delivery platforms; aggregated supply from multiple retailers.
TaskRabbit
Founded 2008; by 2020, ~50,000 taskers in 70+ cities. Pioneered task-based gig work (furniture assembly, moving, cleaning). Acquired by IKEA (2017) for $204 million.

Archaeological Finds

The material artifacts of the platform economy are ephemeral and digital, but several physical traces remain. (1) Data centers: massive, climate-controlled facilities housing servers for AWS, Google, Facebook, and others. The Prineville Data Center (Oregon, 2010–) and similar facilities are monuments to platform infrastructure. (2) Smartphones: iPhones and Android devices are the primary interface to platforms; billions are in circulation. (3) Venture-capital documents: pitch decks, term sheets, and business plans from Uber, Airbnb, and others are archived at Stanford, MIT, and other institutions. (4) Source code: early versions of platforms (Napster, 1999; Friendster, 2002) are preserved in software archives. (5) User-generated content: billions of reviews, photos, and messages on platforms are the primary record of platform culture. (6) Regulatory filings: SEC filings, antitrust complaints, and labor lawsuits document the platforms' business models and disputes. (7) News archives: thousands of articles in the New York Times, Wall Street Journal, and tech media chronicle platform emergence and controversy. Unlike physical artifacts (ships, machines), platform archaeology is primarily digital and archival.

Comparison Panel

Differences
Industrial Revolution was capital-intensive (factories, railroads); platforms are data-intensive (algorithms, networks). Industrial Revolution created mass employment; platforms minimize employment. Industrial Revolution was national; platforms are global. Industrial Revolution's externalities were visible (pollution); platforms' externalities are opaque (data extraction, algorithmic bias).
Similarities
Both promised efficiency and convenience; both concentrated wealth and power; both externalized costs onto workers and society; both faced regulatory backlash.
Platform Economy (2000–2020)
Digital networks, algorithmic matching, and data extraction. Decentralized ownership (peer-to-peer) but centralized control (platform algorithm). Externalities: worker precarity, housing inflation, data privacy, market concentration. Regulatory response: labor reclassification, data protection (GDPR), antitrust investigations.
Industrial Revolution (1760–1914)
Steam power, factories, railroads, and mass production. Centralized ownership and control; labor concentrated in factories. Externalities: pollution, child labor, urban overcrowding. Regulatory response: labor laws, environmental protection, antitrust (Sherman Act, 1890).

Interesting Facts

  • ARPANET's first message, October 29, 1969, was 'LO' (intended: 'LOGIN'); the system crashed after two characters.
  • Tim Berners-Lee did not patent the World Wide Web; CERN released it into the public domain, enabling its rapid adoption.
  • Amazon was unprofitable for its first seven years (1994–2001); investors tolerated losses because of growth and network effects.
  • Uber's 2009 launch coincided with the financial crisis; surge pricing during emergencies (2012 Hurricane Sandy) sparked backlash.
  • Airbnb's founders photographed and redesigned listings themselves in 2011 to improve conversion rates; this 'growth hacking' became a template.
  • Facebook's 'move fast and break things' motto (2009–2014) reflected platform culture's disregard for regulation and externalities.
  • Google's 'Don't be evil' motto (1998) was dropped from its code of conduct in 2018 amid antitrust and labor concerns.
  • By 2020, Amazon's cloud division (AWS) generated ~$45 billion in revenue but was subsidized by e-commerce losses; this cross-subsidization enabled market dominance.
  • Uber's 'blitzkrieg' expansion strategy (2010–2015) involved launching in dozens of cities simultaneously, often illegally, to establish network effects before regulators could respond.
  • TaskRabbit's acquisition by IKEA (2017) for $204 million was a bet that gig labor could be integrated into retail; the strategy largely failed.
  • WeWork's 2019 IPO collapse (valuation fell from $47 billion to ~$3 billion) exposed the fragility of platforms relying on venture-capital subsidies and real-estate arbitrage.
  • By 2020, Amazon controlled ~40% of US e-commerce; Google and Facebook controlled ~60% of digital advertising; Apple and Google controlled ~99% of mobile operating systems.
  • Algorithmic pricing on Uber and Airbnb varies by location, time, and user behavior; surge pricing can increase prices 2–10x, raising fairness questions.
  • Platform workers (Uber drivers, Airbnb hosts, TaskRabbit taskers) have no collective bargaining power; algorithmic management prevents unionization.
  • Data breaches and privacy scandals (Facebook–Cambridge Analytica, 2018; Equifax, 2017) revealed that platforms' business models depend on extracting and monetizing personal data.
  • The 'gig economy' promised flexibility and autonomy; studies show platform workers earn $15–20/hour after expenses, with no benefits or job security.
  • By 2020, platforms faced regulatory challenges in multiple jurisdictions: labor reclassification (UK, California), antitrust investigations (US, EU), data protection (GDPR), and housing restrictions (Paris, Barcelona).
  • The COVID-19 pandemic (2020) exposed platform vulnerabilities: Uber and Lyft faced driver shortages; Airbnb faced cancellations; Amazon faced supply-chain disruptions. Yet platforms also became essential infrastructure for remote work and delivery.
  • Platform culture valorized 'disruption' and 'innovation' while externalizing costs; the phrase 'move fast and break things' became a symbol of Silicon Valley's hubris.
  • By 2020, the 'techlash' had begun: antitrust lawsuits, labor organizing, data-privacy activism, and calls for regulation challenged the platform economy's legitimacy.

Quotations

  • Text
    The Internet is not something that you just dump something on. It's not a big truck. It's a series of tubes.
    Context
    Exemplified policymakers' ignorance of platform technology and contributed to regulatory lag.
    Attribution
    Senator Ted Stevens, 2006 (misquoting network architecture; became a meme)
  • Text
    Move fast and break things. Unless you are breaking stuff, you are not moving fast enough.
    Context
    Captured Silicon Valley's ethos of disruption without accountability; later abandoned amid regulatory scrutiny.
    Attribution
    Mark Zuckerberg, Facebook motto (2009–2014)
  • Text
    We're not a taxi company, we're a technology company.
    Context
    Claim to avoid labor and taxi regulations; disputed by labor boards and courts in UK, California, and elsewhere.
    Attribution
    Uber executives, repeated in regulatory disputes (2010s)
  • Text
    The sharing economy is really the sharing of excess capacity.
    Context
    Framed Airbnb as peer-to-peer sharing; critics noted it was increasingly commercial landlords renting apartments.
    Attribution
    Airbnb CEO Brian Chesky, 2013
  • Text
    We have always been in the business of selling ads.
    Context
    Revealed that Facebook's primary business model was extracting user data and selling targeted advertising, not connecting people.
    Attribution
    Mark Zuckerberg, Facebook earnings call, 2009
  • Text
    Your data is a valuable asset. We're just helping you monetize it.
    Context
    Platforms claimed to empower users; in reality, they extracted data and paid users nothing.
    Attribution
    Generic platform pitch (paraphrased), 2010s
  • Text
    If you're not paying for the product, you are the product.
    Context
    Captured the economics of free platforms: users provide data, platforms sell advertising.
    Attribution
    Attributed to various sources (Jaron Lanier, 2010s)
  • Text
    Algorithms don't have bias; they just reflect the data.
    Context
    Platforms claimed neutrality; critics showed that algorithms embedded human choices about fairness and profit.
    Attribution
    Generic platform defense (paraphrased), 2010s–2020s
  • Text
    We're disrupting the taxi industry, not replacing it.
    Context
    Claimed Uber would complement taxis; instead, it displaced millions of taxi drivers and restructured labor.
    Attribution
    Uber executives, 2014
  • Text
    The future is a place where you can earn money on your own terms.
    Context
    Promised autonomy; reality was algorithmic management, low pay, and no benefits.
    Attribution
    Uber marketing slogan, 2010s

Sources

  • Note
    Original TCP/IP specification; foundational technical document.
    Type
    primary
    Year
    1974
    Title
    A Protocol for Packet Network Intercommunication
    Author
    Cerf, Vint; Kahn, Robert E.
  • Note
    Original proposal for the World Wide Web; submitted to CERN.
    Type
    primary
    Year
    1989
    Title
    Information Management: A Proposal
    Author
    Berners-Lee, Tim
  • Note
    Articulated Amazon's long-term vision and willingness to sacrifice short-term profit for growth.
    Type
    primary
    Year
    1997
    Title
    1997 Letter to Amazon Shareholders
    Author
    Bezos, Jeff
  • Note
    Official business models, financials, and risk disclosures; primary source for platform economics.
    Type
    primary
    Year
    1997–2020
    Title
    Amazon, Google, Facebook, Uber, Airbnb IPO and Annual Reports
    Author
    SEC Filings (10-K, S-1)
  • Note
    Marxist analysis of platform business models, data extraction, and labor; influential critical framework.
    Type
    secondary
    Year
    2017
    Title
    Platform Capitalism
    Author
    Srnicek, Nick
  • Note
    Comprehensive critique of data extraction and behavioral manipulation by platforms; argues for regulation.
    Type
    secondary
    Year
    2019
    Title
    The Age of Surveillance Capitalism
    Author
    Zuboff, Shoshana
  • Note
    Analysis of platform labor, algorithmic management, and worker rights; legal and policy perspective.
    Type
    secondary
    Year
    2020
    Title
    The Right to Disconnect
    Author
    Keller, Daphne
  • Note
    Insider account of venture-capital culture and platform growth strategies; narrative history.
    Type
    secondary
    Year
    2019
    Title
    Burn Rate: How I Crashed an American Startup
    Author
    Roose, Kevin
  • Note
    Analysis of platform dominance, network effects, and market concentration; business perspective.
    Type
    secondary
    Year
    2017
    Title
    The Four: The Hidden DNA of Amazon, Apple, Facebook, and Google
    Author
    Galloway, Scott
  • Note
    Policy analysis of platform regulation, antitrust, and labor law; regulatory perspective.
    Type
    secondary
    Year
    2020
    Title
    The Politics of Platform Regulation
    Author
    Karpf, David
  • Note
    Ethnographic study of platform labor (TaskRabbit, Uber); worker perspective.
    Type
    secondary
    Year
    2017
    Title
    Digital Piecework
    Author
    Dubal, Veena
  • Note
    Empirical analysis of gig work growth; shows platforms' role in labor-market transformation.
    Type
    secondary
    Year
    2016
    Title
    The Rise and Nature of Alternative Work Arrangements in the United States, 1995–2015
    Author
    Katz, Lawrence F.; Krueger, Alan B.
  • Note
    Study of platform worker vulnerability; shows lack of safety nets and collective power.
    Type
    secondary
    Year
    2020
    Title
    What Happens to Workers When Platforms Shut Down?
    Author
    Vallas, Steven; Schor, Juliet B.
  • Note
    Analysis of platform governance, content moderation, and algorithmic decision-making; media studies perspective.
    Type
    secondary
    Year
    2018
    Title
    Custodians of the Internet
    Author
    Gillespie, Tarleton

Source of Truth

🗺 POCKET MAP
🗺 Museum Map
Galleries
Plan your visit
Your route
…tracing your steps…
QR code linking back to this exhibit
SCAN TO RETURN TO THIS EXHIBIT