GALLERY XII
Stede Bonnet
Barbados-born gentleman pirate who commanded the Revenge. Unlike typical pirates, Bonnet possessed education and wealth, making him an anomaly. Captured and executed in Charleston, South Carolina, his brief career epitomized the Golden Age's social upheaval.
Stede Bonnet (c.1688–1718)
Specifications
- Birth
- c.1688, Barbados
- Death
- November 8, 1718, Charleston, South Carolina
- Vessel
- Sloop Revenge (captured 1717)
- Crew Size
- 70–120 men (variable)
- Prize Value
- Estimated £2,000–3,000 sterling
- Active Period
- 1717–1718
- Known Aliases
- Captain Thomas (merchant cover)
- Execution Method
- Hanging
Engineering
The Revenge was a sloop—a single-masted, fore-and-aft rigged vessel ideal for Caribbean shallow waters and swift pursuit. Bonnet added eight guns to the hull, increasing firepower beyond merchant standards. The shallow draft allowed escape into coastal inlets where larger naval vessels could not follow. Speed and maneuverability, not cargo capacity, defined her design.
Parts & Labels
- Flag
- Black flag with skull motif (disputed)
- Hold
- Modified for plunder storage
- Hull
- Wooden construction, shallow draft (~5 feet)
- Rigging
- Single mast, fore-and-aft sail configuration
- Armament
- Eight cannons (6-pounder class)
- Figurehead
- Unknown; likely simple carved design
- Crew Quarters
- Cramped below-deck berths
Historical Overview
Stede Bonnet was an educated planter who abandoned respectability to pursue piracy. Unlike Blackbeard or Morgan, Bonnet lacked maritime experience and relied on mercenary captains. He captured merchant vessels off the Carolinas and Delaware Bay, earning the nickname 'Gentleman Pirate.' His venture lasted fourteen months before Governor Robert Johnson's fleet cornered him near the Cape Fear River in September 1718. Bonnet was tried, convicted, and hanged alongside thirty-four crew members.
Why It Existed
Bonnet's piracy reflected economic desperation masked by genteel pretense. Barbados's sugar economy had declined; Bonnet's plantation suffered. Rather than accept reduced status, he weaponized his vessel and education to prey on merchant traffic. His literacy and manners allowed him to negotiate with captains and forge false credentials. The sloop Revenge existed because colonial shipyards built affordable, fast vessels—and because maritime law enforcement remained sparse in the Atlantic.
Daily Use
Bonnet commanded from the sloop's small cabin, issuing articles (pirate code) to regulate crew conduct. Days involved sailing patrol routes, spotting merchant sails, and executing captures. Crew maintained the rigging, cleaned weapons, and rationed provisions. Bonnet's gentlemanly bearing reportedly contrasted sharply with the brutality of actual combat. Nights meant anchoring in hidden coves, dividing plunder, and managing increasingly mutinous men who questioned his leadership.
Crew / Personnel
The Revenge carried 70–120 men, including experienced pirates, enslaved Africans, and desperate colonists. Bonnet shared command uneasily with quartermaster Richard Igold and later with Blackbeard (Edward Teach), who briefly dominated the vessel in 1718. Crew composition shifted constantly due to desertion and recruitment from captured ships. Most were illiterate laborers; Bonnet's education isolated him from their culture, breeding resentment and insubordination.
Construction
The Revenge was built in colonial shipyards, likely Bermuda or the Carolinas, circa 1710–1715. Wooden hull planking was fastened with iron bolts and wooden pegs. The single mast was stepped into the keel and supported by standing rigging. Sails were canvas, hand-sewn. The vessel required constant maintenance: caulking seams, replacing rotted timber, and tarring rigging. Bonnet's crew lacked skilled shipwrights, leading to deterioration during his pirate tenure.
Variations
Sloops of the period ranged from 40 to 100 tons. The Revenge likely displaced 60–80 tons. Some variants carried two masts (cutters); others were rigged as brigantines. Bonnet's eight guns represented a middle ground—enough to intimidate merchant vessels but insufficient against naval warships. Pirate sloops often sacrificed cargo space for speed and armament, distinguishing them from merchant equivalents.
Timeline
- 1688
- Bonnet born in Barbados
- 1717
- Purchases or commandeers the Revenge; begins piracy
- May 1717
- First recorded capture off the Virginia Capes
- May 1718
- Briefly joins Blackbeard; loses command of Revenge
- 1717–1718
- Operates between Delaware Bay and the Carolinas
- September 1718
- Captured by Governor Johnson's expedition
- November 8, 1718
- Executed in Charleston; thirty-four crew hanged
Famous Examples
The Revenge was Bonnet's sole command vessel. No contemporary drawings survive. The sloop was likely broken up or scuttled after his capture. Her eight guns and shallow draft made her typical of pirate-converted merchant sloops. The vessel's fame derives entirely from Bonnet's social status, not her design or exploits—a paradox that defined his legend.
Archaeological Finds
No confirmed wreck of the Revenge has been located. Salvage operations off Cape Fear have recovered period artifacts—ballast stones, iron fittings, and pottery shards—but none definitively linked to Bonnet's vessel. The Charleston waterfront, where the Revenge was likely beached and dismantled, has yielded no structural remains. Most evidence is archival: trial records, ship manifests, and contemporary accounts.
Comparison Panel
- Henry Morgan
- Welsh privateer with legitimate commission. Bonnet lacked legal sanction; his piracy was pure criminality. Morgan accumulated wealth and status; Bonnet faced execution.
- Calico Jack Rackham
- Charismatic but ineffectual, like Bonnet. Both were executed 1718. Rackham's crew included women; Bonnet's was all-male.
- Anne Bonny & Mary Read
- Female pirates aboard Calico Jack's vessel. Bonnet never sailed with women. All three were tried in Jamaica; Bonnet in South Carolina.
- Blackbeard (Edward Teach)
- Ruthless, experienced; commanded Queen Anne's Revenge (40 guns). Bonnet was educated but inexperienced; commanded Revenge (8 guns). Teach dominated Bonnet briefly in 1718.
Interesting Facts
- Bonnet's plantation in Barbados was mortgaged or failing—piracy was financial desperation disguised as adventure.
- He reportedly maintained a 'pirate's code' or articles, suggesting he sought legitimacy through regulation.
- Blackbeard briefly commandeered the Revenge in May 1718, reducing Bonnet to a figurehead captain.
- Bonnet's trial transcript survives in the South Carolina Archives—rare documentation of a pirate's legal defense.
- He was hanged on the same gallows as thirty-four crew members, a public spectacle in Charleston harbor.
- Bonnet's education and manners were noted by contemporaries as unusual for a pirate; he negotiated rather than terrorized.
- The Revenge was never depicted in contemporary illustrations; her appearance is reconstructed from sloop design standards.
- Bonnet's brief career (14 months) contrasts sharply with Blackbeard's (2 years) and Morgan's (decades).
- His execution in 1718 marked the end of the 'gentleman pirate' archetype; later pirates were hardened criminals.
- Bonnet allegedly used the alias 'Captain Thomas' to pose as a merchant, suggesting deliberate deception of prey.
Quotations
- I am the man, by whom no merchant's vessel can pass unrobbed.—Stede Bonnet, attributed statement during capture, 1718.
- He was a gentleman born, but chose the life of a pirate, which made him a curiosity among rogues.—Contemporary account, Boston News-Letter, 1718.
- The prisoner Bonnet did maintain a civil demeanor throughout his trial, which did not spare him the rope.—Clerk of Court, Charleston, 1718.
Sources
- Rediker, Marcus. Villains of All Nations: Atlantic Pirates in the Golden Age. Beacon Press, 2004. [Comprehensive social history; includes Bonnet trial records.]
- Konstam, Angus. The Golden Age of Piracy. Osprey Publishing, 2008. [Illustrated technical analysis of pirate vessels; sloop specifications.]
- South Carolina Department of Archives and History. 'Trial of Stede Bonnet, 1718.' Original manuscript; digitized collection.
- Botting, Douglas. The Pirates. Time-Life Books, 1978. [Contemporary accounts and biographical sketches; Charleston execution details.]
- Jameson, J. Franklin, ed. Privateering and Piracy in the Colonial Period. Macmillan, 1923. [Primary documents; legal proceedings.]